All Natural Cheeses

View as Grid List
Sort by
Display per page

All Natural Cheeses Gift Box

Each gift box contains a your choice of five 8oz packages of our All Natural cheese, one summer sausage (Old Fashioned, Hunters or Jalapeno & Cheese), and a package of six-count Babybels. Excludes Habanero selection. A perfect gift for any time of year! **Please leave your cheese flavor preferences in the Special Instructions box at payment or email us at Or, you can trust us to make a tasty selection for you! CURRENTLY OUT OF BABY BEL - WE WILL SUBSTITUTE ANOTHER PIECE OF CHEESE.

Cheddar Wine

Chedda Wine is made using the normal cheddar process but with a twist. Tawny port wine is added to give this robust cheese a hint of wine flavor. Chedda Wine compliments many wines and is great to serve at tasting parties


Colby is a softer, milder cheese that contains more moisture and has a shorter curing process. Colby has a mild and slightly sweet taste.

Habanero,hot,hot.The first bite starts off slow then really heats up. Try it alone or in your chili.Sure to clear out your head and maybe even give you watery eyes.


Havarti (huh-var-tee) has a hidden intensity that makes it a favorite for both entertaining and cooking. Wonderful on salads or sliced in sandwiches. Melts best when shredded.

Heini's Amish Butter 8oz

Heini's Amish Butter Cheese: Artificial Growth Hormone Free Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes and Annato coloring. Manufactured by: Bunker Hill Cheese Co INC Millersburg Ohio 44654


Munster Cheese. Choose from our 8oz and 1lb size selections and start snackin'!

Swiss 8oz

With Swissland Cheese Co. located in Berne Indiana a historically Swiss community, you could say we know a thing or two about Swiss cheese. Our Swiss offers a mild, nutty flavor sure to please Swiss-lovers everywhere.